“I envy, truly I envy, those people who pray in simple faith without worrying about how prayer works and how God governs this planet. Alas, for some reason I cannot avoid pondering these imponderables.”
– Philip Yancey
I’ve been pondering a lot of biblical questions lately, and thankfully SpaceKitty has indulged me in at least a few essay length emails on the topic, maybe more. I’d like to get some of the topics down into a more concise summary here so that I might link to my findings for other searchers, but forgive me if this post is still a bit nebulous.
First of all, SK lent me the excellent book The Case for Faith, which by itself cleared up many of the tough questions I had been pondering in my conversations with her. It reaffirmed many of my own suspicions and gave me a few fresh ideas on others. Sometimes, it’s just good to hear an expert on the subject say what you’ve been thinking. The interesting ones for me were #1 Suffering, #3 OT Violence, #4 Hell, and #5 Jesus is the only way. Each was well answered and interesting. I’ll probably post up a favorable review shortly, but check it out if the questions interest you.
Two big questions, or rather topics, remained for me however. The first of which was prayer, the second I’ll tackle in another post. On prayer, questions like “Should we pray for even small desires?”, “Why pray when God already knows the answer?”, and “What about when prayer doesn’t seem to work?” The first question isn’t terribly hard to work out, as God commands us to pray in pretty much all matters. “Do not be anxious about anything, but in everything, by prayer and petition, with thanksgiving, present your requests to God”.
But as for the second one, the best response I’ve heard to this is that since God knows our choices, his plans include our prayers and requests. If he knows no request is made, no plan is made. If he knows a request will be made that he will answer, the answer is planned before we even actually ask. Jesus tells us: “for your Father knows what you need before you ask him.” — yet he still tells us to pray, and he himself prays.
[C.S.] Lewis replied that you could use that same argument against any human activity, not just prayer. “Why wash your hands? If God intends them to be clean, they’ll come clean without your washing them … Why ask for the salt? Why put on your boots? Why do anything?” God could have arranged things so that our bodies nourished themselves miraculously without food, knowledge entered our brains without studying or teachers, umbrellas magically appeared to protect us from rainstorms. God chose a different style of governing the world, however, one which relies on human agency and choice. — [source]
An excellent description in my opinion. The answer is, in my mind, simply because God wants us to ask. It’s definitely biblical that God wants us to seek him and come to him for answers. The prayer is already known, even the answer is already planned, but we need to ask. It’s a willful turning away from ourselves and our own strength and toward God. Someone once put it: “Prayer is the method God has chosen to bestow his blessings.” That makes a lot of sense to me. It’s not to say he doesn’t grant us things we haven’t asked for, or even thought to ask for, but simply asking goes a long way.
And as for the 3rd question of what to make of an answer of “No”, I believe it’s all in how you look at things and seeing the big picture. When I look back over my life, I’ve been blessed to be more or less where I needed to be, when I needed to be there. Had things worked out differently, I would have missed the opportunity. I have faith that God guides our lives and works things out for the best. But I believe that it’s also important to look for answers to prayer in ways we might not expect. In my case I once prayed for the health of a terminal loved one, but as she continued to get worse, God had still granted the request in a different ways. In the midst of her worst days, she had days of surprising clarity that we shared together. She was suffering less, comforted more, and visited by nearly all her family and reunited with her church before death.






